Cocktail Recipe: Vestal's Off Kilter

The bar at Vestal serves up a quirky Northwest take on an unsung classic cocktail
Ariana Vitale behind the bar at Vestal

The Cocktail: Off Kilter
The Bar: Vestal
The Bartender: Ariana Vitale

Drink History Dating back to at least 1916, the Chrysanthemum cocktail, on which the Off Kilter is based, is an unsung classic in which dry vermouth takes a rare starring role, with Bénédictine liqueur as the sidekick, plus a little absinthe to round things out. It was a key inspiration for effervescent Vestal bar manager Ariana Vitale when she was developing the Off Kilter, but she decided to use verjus blanc (which is nonalcoholic) instead of vermouth. The juice of unripe grapes, verjus has a graceful tartness and acidity. Used for cooking in wine-producing regions around the globe for years, it’s now showing up locally on food and drink menus, and provides a creative base for drinks that are lighter on alcohol, like this one. To deliver the Bénédictine herbal notes of the original, Vitale adds yellow Chartreuse (a touch sweeter and softer than the better-known green variety), while keeping the gentle hints of absinthe.

The Twist When building on the Chrysanthemum, Vitale, who was a brand ambassador for Novo Fogo’s cachaça, a Brazilian sugar-cane-based liquor, really wanted to “play around with adding a smoky element.” To achieve that, she added small amounts of two personality-rich whiskeys: SoDo-based Westland Distillery’s peated single malt American whiskey and Kilchoman single malt Scotch whisky, from one of Scotland’s smallest distilleries. These two supply layers of peat and smoke, and mingle with the other herbal tones without getting too heavy. As Vitale says, it “drinks like a stirred, boozy cocktail, but won’t put you on the floor.” The smokiness helps make the Off Kilter an ideal match for the restaurant’s deep forest ambiance (which is remarkable, given that Vestal is on the ground floor of a big Amazon office building), created by the massive open wood-fired hearth, terrariums and plants, candles and twinkle lights shining like stars in the ceiling. The hearth is Vestal’s center and really serves as the home-base restaurant for Josh Henderson (executive chef and founder of the Huxley Wallace Collective). The care taken in making the dishes on Vestal’s creative Northwest, seasonal menu, with items such as super-slow-roasted steelhead with steelhead skin “chicharrones,” matches the meticulous hand-crafting of the drinks at this small but cozy bar.

The Tools Most ingredients can be found at any good local liquor store, though you may have to look online for the verjus blanc (try If you want a giant ice cube, consider buying the Tovolo King ice cube tray on Amazon.

Off Kilter Cocktail Recipe

¼ ounce Pacifique absinthe
Cracked ice
1½ ounces verjus blanc
½ ounce Westland peated single malt whiskey
¼ ounce Kilchoman single malt Scotch whisky
¼ ounce yellow Chartreuse 
Wide orange peel, for garnish

Image by Maria Billorou
The Off Kilter’s smoky, floral aromas shine in an old fashioned–style glass

» Add the absinthe to an old fashioned–style glass or one that’s comparable. Swirl it around so that every inch of the inside of the glass is touched. Discard any remaining absinthe. 

» Fill a cocktail shaker or mixing glass half full of cracked ice. Add the verjus, two single malts and Chartreuse. Stir well.

» Add one really big ice cube or a number of smaller ice cubes to the glass. Strain the mix into the glass. Squeeze the orange peel over the top of the drink and then drop it in.

A note: Vitale uses a perfume dispenser to spray the glass with absinthe, instead of rinsing the glass with it; it helps to conserve product and it looks cool. If you have an extra dispenser, try this method.

Related Content

L’Oursin chef/owner JJ Proville says his bistro's aesthetic—more brass chairs and soft lighting than exposed brick and reclaimed wood—was most influenced by a little coffee table book on French bistros. Cheesy, maybe, but the chef, raised partially in France, knows what he’s doing

Though it may be hard to tell if spring has actually arrived here in Seattle, I do know that our local distillers have sprung into action with a number of new releases sure to tickle the fancy of spirit lovers; read about a few below.

Last week thousands of coffee lovers from around the world flooded Seattle’s Washington State Convention Center, making the pilgrimage to the nation’s coffee capital

Peek into any professional kitchen and it’s not uncommon to find a serious underrepresentation of female chefs and cooks. Women Chefs and Restaurateurs (WCR) wants to make sure those voices are heard at equal volume to their male counterparts