Seattle Culture

A Win for NIMBYs and YIMBYs

By Knute Berger December 19, 2016

Backyard-Cottage-in-Ballard

I can still hear my John Muir Elementary School teacher admonishing us hyperactive second graders that “haste makes waste.” Recent decisions suggest the city of Seattle could learn from that.

Earlier this month a city hearing examiner found that the city’s Office of Planning and Community Development had not done its homework on proposed legislation to allow more backyard cottages and mother-in-law apartments in single-family neighborhoods. Generally, these are a good thing for many of reasons: they provide more housing, they can help current homeowners stay in place.

Mother-in-laws have been allowed since 1993 and cottages, on a limited basis, since 2006. Relatively few cottages—technically known as Detached Accessory Dwelling Units, or DADUs—have been built, so the city council’s Mike O’Brien proposed to ease restrictions on them by not requiring parking places be provided, allowing them on smaller lots, allowing them to be bigger and taller, and removing the requirement that the property owner live on site for at least six months of the year. Some 82,000 lots throughout the city would be eligible for such units.

The Queen Community Council objected to the city’s approval of the plan arguing that its impact hadn’t been fully studied and its impacts had been dismissed as “non-significant,” although the arguments for it were that its impact would, in fact, be significant. The Office of Planning hoped that it would unleash a flood of needed housing in single-family neighborhoods. Skeptics said that might be true, but as written, it might also unleash a new level of gentrification because commercial developers could buy properties and drive up their values. In other words, instead of it being a grassroots way to create more affordable housing, it could create more unaffordable housing and displacement, especially in South Seattle.

The hearing Examiner found that the city did not comply with the State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) by failing to do a thorough, unbiased study of the possible impacts of the ordinance, and has ordered Seattle do a full Environmental Impact Statement. It admonished the Office of Planning for becoming cheerleaders and rushing approval instead of doing its homework. 

There is a temptation for many agencies to take shortcuts. In January of this year, the same hearing examiner, Sue A. Tanner, also found the city had done an incomplete environmental review of a controversial mountain bike trail in the Cheasty Green Belt and was therefore out of compliance with SEPA. She reversed the Parks Department’s approval of the project.

Personally, I hope the EIS of DADUs finds that some version of ordinance will work—I favor keeping the residency requirement, but also think more and larger units are a good,even necessary, idea. I also think the examiner is right to require a better, fuller analysis.

Backyard cottages and mother-in-law apartments are not the answer to housing needs, but they are part of it. They won’t replace the need for more multi-family housing on a larger scale, but they can be a useful piece of the urban puzzle. I also think that data should not be the enemy of either NIMBYs or YIMBYs. Better and fuller environmental review is a good thing.

Follow Us

Seattle: Again The Place To Be

Seattle: Again The Place To Be

Seattle nears pre-pandemic visitor levels in impressive turnaround

Visit Seattle released preliminary figures for 2023 at its annual meeting Wednesday, and found that the region hosted 37.8 million visitors last year, an 8.9% increase from 2022. That’s just 10% less than in 2019, the last full year before the pandemic.

Foot Traffic Rises Again in Downtown Seattle

Foot Traffic Rises Again in Downtown Seattle

Downtown Seattle Association: Slow recovery continues

Nearly 1.9 million visitors came downtown last month. Downtown averaged 85,000 daily workers, a 16% increase from February 2023. That, however, is only 57% compared to the same period in 2020, right before the pandemic.

Cream of the Chop: Top Chef Kaleena Bliss

Cream of the Chop: Top Chef Kaleena Bliss

Washington native competes on popular Bravo cooking competition

Seattleites will spot a familiar face on the latest season of Top Chef, set in Wisconsin this year. Chef Kaleena Bliss competes for the coveted title on the longstanding cooking competition franchise, now in its 21st year.

Washington’s Woeful Gender-Pay Gap

Washington’s Woeful Gender-Pay Gap

Women across the state earn significantly less than men

Women across the state made $18,4000 less in average wages than men in 2022. New research from the National Partnership for Women and Families found that only Utah has a larger discrepancy, at $20,649.