Hotel Theodore's Chic New Restaurant Walks the Line Between Old and New Seattle

Rider combines a love of fire and sea
Rider's Argentine-style grill gives many dishes a kiss of fire (like the steelhead plated below), but the cold seafood platters are just as nice

This article appears in print in the May 2018 issue. Click here to subscribe.

With Seattle rapidly growing and increasingly diversifying, it’s more and more difficult for a restaurant to create a concept—or a menu—that pleases everyone. But Rider, open since November in the ground floor of the trendy new Hotel Theodore, is trying, by walking the line between forest and ocean, predictable and surprising, old Seattle and new. It’s equal parts dark, broody bar and bright, contemporary dining room. (Imagine a marriage of The Whale Wins and Miller’s Guild.)

“With Seattle being home to so many cultures and influences, we wanted to have that come through in small ways in the menu,” says chef David Nichols, most recently executive chef at Euro drinking establishment Queen Anne Beerhall, who launched Rider with industry vet Jonathan Fleming (formerly of Ciudad and Bar Sajor). “This city has seen an influx of people moving here—[we wanted to pair] local Pacific Northwest ingredients with bold flavors that our guests can enjoy.”

Those bold flavors show up in the likes of preserved lemon and harissa to make an otherwise unsurprising tuna tartare ($17) exceptional and as kimchi to brighten Brussels sprouts ($10). But because this is a place of dichotomy, there are also seafood platters (starting at $40) featuring an assortment of spot prawns, oysters, crabs and the like served either raw or only just cooked. The other big menu influence here is an obvious one from the moment you walk in: The open kitchen houses an Argentine-style top-feeding wood grill so massive that its majestic fire catches every eye in the house. It warms the room, both figuratively and literally, provides an all-day fireplace scent and serves as a primal cooking source for dishes like whole Idaho trout ($34). As you can tell, the menu is expansive, the result of having a whopping 860 square feet of kitchen space to cook in.

Come during happy hour and sit in the bar for pub burgers ($9) and oysters ($1.50 each at 3 p.m., $2 at 4 p.m. and $2.50 at 5 p.m.). Beware the cocktail prices, though—I couldn’t resist the old fashioned made with local barrel-aged bourbon from 2Bar Spirits, but it was $17 ($20, really, after tax and included service charge). That’s something old Seattle still has a hard time swallowing.

Must Try: On one visit this winter, crispy sunchokes ($10) were deliciously flavored with fish sauce and garlic, and served with wriggly bonito flakes on top. This spring, look for them paired with something pickled and lighter.

RiderDowntown 619 Pine St.; 206.859.4242.

Related Content

By day, Carolyn Sellar looks after apes, primates, lions and tigers. By night, she’s one of the country’s foremost authorities on whiskey.

If you ordered dessert at a fancy restaurant, and just learned that the insides of a roasted Japanese sweet potato found new life as a mousse, only to be layered with pear compote and glazed with Valrhona white chocolate after being reshaped into

If there’s a trendy new culinary craze in Seattle, chances are Jody Hall is behind it. Hall, of course, founded Seattle’s iconic Cupcake Royale back in 2003. At the time, it was one of the first cupcake cafés west of New York City.

Thanks to Christian Chan, Seattle will soon become the place where fine dining meets fast food.

In April, Chan will open Bloom, a grab-and-go “fast-fine” restaurant the likes of which he says Seattle has never seen.