Skip to content

Arts

Read More ›

Bad Data on Demolitions

Numbers on demolitions in Seattle highlighted in an Arcade magazine article were incomplete

demolitionsseattle_0

Last month, I wrote a blog post about the seeming explosion of demolitions in the city. I cited an article in ARCADE magazine by Schema Design that plotted demolition permits from 2005-2009, and from 2010-2015 (projected). A graphic that ran with the original article, not my story, heightened the dramatic sense of demolition being more common and widespread.

I was shocked by the ARCADE numbers and images—they underscored my sense that Seattle’s physical environment is changing dramatically. I said in my story that the numbers needed more analysis and I mentioned how Portland’s mayor had proposed to tax demolitions there.

I should have done more of that analysis myself before the fact. I am sorry I did not.

Turns out, the numbers in the ARCADE story were incomplete, and the conclusion of a demo explosion was vastly overstated. I said the number of demo permits was up eight times over previous numbers based on the 2005-09 figures in ARCADE, but I now know that those didn’t represent a full picture of demo permits. ARCADE has now posted a clarification with the article and hopefully will be updating its story with accurate, more complete data.

Others have weighed in. Ethan Phelps-Goodman at The Urbanist dug through the numbers and determined that the demolition of housing units is relatively stable over the last 20 years. Permits were up, he says, in 2014, by about 60%, but appeared to be declining. His conclusion: “The articles in ARCADE and Seattle Magazine no doubt tap into a widespread feeling that there are a lot of demolitions. As a value judgment, people can disagree on what constitutes ‘a lot.’ What should be clear from the data, however, is that there’s no explosion in demolitions. In fact, the pace of demolitions is entirely average.”

Roger Valdez, a strong advocate for more development, has criticized me—and my story—for fanning a sense of panic among people, that the city is being bulldozed. In a Facebook comment, he suggested that I follow up this way: “Yes, our city is changing and using qualitative measures it sure might feel like a crisis. But the numbers don’t bear that out. It’d be great if you’d do another post pointing out what you think this dissonance be between the data and the felt experience.”

Great idea.

I’ll explore that in future posts.

 

Wait, There's an Entire Day Dedicated to Museum Store Gift Shopping?

Wait, There’s an Entire Day Dedicated to Museum Store Gift Shopping?

Now in its 10th year, Museum Store Sunday returns Nov. 29 with special deals and plenty of reasons to explore some of the Seattle area's most creative places to shop.

I’ve always thought museum gift shops are among the best places to buy presents. In fact, they’re some of my favorite places to shop, period. I love the store at Cascadia Art Museum in Edmonds (one year, I bought nearly all of my 9-year-old daughter’s birthday presents there), along with the ones at the Frye…

Lucy Tan's New Novel Studies Complex Relationships

Lucy Tan’s New Novel Studies Complex Relationships

The Seattle author’s Tiger’s Mouth explores the divides between wealth and opportunity, and what happens when ambition tests the bonds of friendship.

When Chen and Owens meet during a summer internship at a health-tech company in New York, the only thing they seem to have in common is their shared first name: Jack. Chen is the striving son of Chinese American parents who own a catering business in Queens, and Owens’ last name is on the building—his…

Actualize AiR Launches a Curatorial Residency Program

Actualize AiR Launches a Curatorial Residency Program

The local organization tapped Once Removed—an ongoing art installation project—to take over its gallery for three months. 

Over the past three years, Actualize AiR, the woman-founded and artist-led organization based in Pioneer Square, has grown to be one of the most interesting incubators of creativity in Seattle. In September, Actualize announced the recipient of its first-ever curatorial residency program—in which the curator would be given the keys to its street-level Yesler Gallery…

Rearview Mirror: Fresh Faces, a Peruvian Feast, and the Book I Could Not Put Down 

Rearview Mirror: Fresh Faces, a Peruvian Feast, and the Book I Could Not Put Down 

Things I did, saw, ate, learned, or read in the past week (or so).

SPOOKY STAGES Last week, the much-anticipated Ghost Stories opened at Pacific Northwest Ballet. The four-ballet rep included two works from Alejandro Cerrudo (Silent Ghost and PACOPEPEPLUTO), George Balanchine’s La Sonnambula (which hadn’t been performed by the company since 2007), and a world premiere, The Raven, choreographed by PNB principal dancer Kyle Davis. It was recently…