Skip to content

The Best Cookies in Seattle

We ate many, many cookies in our research to find the city’s best bakeries—these are our favorites

By Chelsea Lin November 2, 2018

1_83

This article originally appeared in the November 2018 issue of Seattle magazine.

This article appears in print in the November 2018 issue, as part of our “The Best Neighborhood Bakeries,” cover story. Click here to subscribe.

1. Metropolitan Market
Multiple locations
The Cookie—perfect, oversize chocolate chip cookie with walnuts, crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside. 

2. Lowrider Baking Company 
Farmers’ markets

Birthday Cake—a balanced, tangy sweet white chocolate cookie with sprinkles. Photograph by Alex Crook

3. Hello Robin
Capitol Hill, 522 19th Ave. E; 206.735.7970

Mackles’more—graham cracker with s’more cookie and Theo chocolate chunk. Photograph by Sarah Flotard

4. Dahlia Bakery
Belltown, 2001 Fourth Ave.; 206.441.4540

Peanut butter sandwich cookie—with creamy peanut butter filling. Photograph by Ed Anderson

5. Bakery Nouveau
Multiple locations

Oatmeal raisin—a crisp, chewy and utterly massive cookie. Photograph by Bakery Nouveau

 

Follow Us

Restaurant Roundup: Death & Co. and Japanese-Italian Fusion

Restaurant Roundup: Death & Co. and Japanese-Italian Fusion

Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.

In the aftermath of the violence at Bite of Seattle, the city’s other food festivals are in unfamiliar territory. Organizers of the upcoming Panda Fest Seattle want to highlight a few features that may help alleviate concerns about the event’s safety. Tickets are required to gain entrance to Fisher Pavilion at Seattle Center, and as…

Let Him Cook: Matt Broussard’s Rise From Restaurant Chef to Social Media Star

Let Him Cook: Matt Broussard’s Rise From Restaurant Chef to Social Media Star

With a forthcoming cookbook and a Capitol Hill restaurant, the Seattle chef is taking his laid-back approach beyond the screen.

Matt Broussard doesn’t know how to describe his food. The chef’s forthcoming cookbook, Now We’re Cooking, has everything from his grandma’s dolmades—grape leaves stuffed with lamb and rice cooked in duck fat—to cantaloupe gazpacho and seared tuna steaks coated in fennel furikake. It’s a culinary hodgepodge that defies categorization, but Broussard defies categorization himself. “I…

Why Seattle Magazine Loves Great State Burger!

Why Seattle Magazine Loves Great State Burger!

In the outside world, Seattle is known for its coffee, seafood and recently its thriving food scene. For those of us who have lived here for years, we grew up with Dicks, Red Mill, Red Robin and more, we have an innate love for the seemingly humble hamburger. The new entrant to the Seattle burger…

Island Reset: Chef Nick Green Finds Vashon

Island Reset: Chef Nick Green Finds Vashon

After years cooking in Japan, Italy, and beyond, Green is bringing a steady hand to The Hardware Store, the community's longtime gathering place. 

I met Nick Green ten years ago when he was chef de cuisine at the Willows Inn on Lummi Island, long before The New York Times published its investigations into alleged misconduct at the restaurant and accusations against its former chef, Blaine Wetzel. Back then, I stumbled into my first position in the vaunted halls…