Skip to content

Seattle City Council Debates Library Levy

The most controversial aspect of the proposal: eliminating library fines

By Erica C. Barnett April 16, 2019

The interior view of Seattle public library
The interior view of Seattle public library

Mayor Jenny Durkan’s proposal to renew Seattle’s library levy and increase it from $123 million to $213 million would accomplish a number of things: add hours to three branches; allow four others to open on Fridays; provide more funding for digital materials; upgrade Internet access for library patrons; and give four branches a seismic upgrade. It will also shift some funding from other areas, like the cable franchise fee, to the levy, which Durkan’s plan calls a more “sustainable” funding source.

In all, the plan, which will appear on the August 6 ballot, would represent an initial property tax increase of up to 11.9 cents for every $1,000 of property value, compared to an initial tax increase of 15 cents per $1,000 when the levy passed in 2012. (The actual tax varies after the first year while the total amount collected increases by no more than 1 percent a year). That would amount to about $7 a month for the owner of a median, $722,000 house in Seattle.

By far the most controversial aspect of the seven-year levy is the proposal to eliminate fines for overdue materials, which would cost $8 million over the life of the levy. (The library takes in about $900,000 a year in fines, plus $200,000 in fees for materials that are not returned; Durkan’s proposal would do away with fines, but not fees.) 

Seattle wouldn’t be the first city to eliminate fines. Studies from other cities that have done this—either on a permanent or pilot basis—have shown that it’s an effective way to ensure that low-income residents (who are less able to pay fines and face more barriers to returning materials) have access to the library. And though it may seem counter intuitive, libraries that eliminated fines found that people were more likely to return materials, and to do so on time.

At a meeting of the City Council’s special library levy committee meeting last week, council staffer Asha Venkataraman explained this conclusion. First, she noted, fines really are a barrier to access: About one in every five library cardholders in Seattle currently has a blocked account, meaning that they can’t access library materials unless they pay their fines. The areas of the city with the largest numbers of blocked accounts and the highest average outstanding fines, are mostly in Southeast Seattle, plus parts of far north Seattle—both areas with lower average incomes and more people of color. Library patrons must have an active account to access the library’s computers. Seattle library’s own study of its users found that the areas where people were most likely to rely on computers in library branches were the same areas where people were most likely to lose their access to the library because of unpaid fines.

Venkataraman also cited a San Francisco study that looked into eliminating library fines. The study found that patrons in cities that had partly or completely eliminated fines returned materials at the same rate or slightly faster, and that circulation of library materials increased overall (which makes sense, because when people fail to return books, the number of books in the system is reduced and circulation goes down.) The study also found that a major reason people avoided going to the library to have their accounts restored wasn’t because they didn’t have the few dollars needed; rather it was “the negative interaction of having to go and pay off fines.” In other words, they didn’t want to have a potentially embarrassing public interaction with a library worker.

Council president Bruce Harrell expressed concern last week that eliminating fines might discourage people from doing their civic responsibility, and suggested (perhaps tongue in cheek) that if the city is going to eliminate fines, they should also eliminate fees for people who simply fail to return books. Harrell also suggested that the city create a system where people who want to pay can do so, but people who don’t want to pay won’t be penalized.

“I don’t understand the policy reasons for waiving millions of dollars when some people might be willing to pay,” Harrell said.

Council members indicated that they were interested in adding a few items to the plan, including extended weeknight hours (council member O’Brien); adding two new security officers to the system (council member Teresa Mosqueda); funding more case managers to connect homeless patrons to housing and services (Mosqueda again) and adding air conditioning and elevators at the Columbia City, Greenlake, and University branches. Some of these are formal amendments, others are items for future discussion; all would add millions to the levy.

City council member Debora Juarez, who chairs the library levy committee, said at last Thursday’s public hearing on the levy that the amendments “all make sense and are great.” At the same time, Juarez cautioned against adding so much to the levy that voters would find it difficult to vote yes.

Follow Us

New Filing Fix Can Help Tame Your Taxes

New Filing Fix Can Help Tame Your Taxes

Free site aims to untangle tax questions

For many, filing taxes is akin to deciphering an ancient cryptic scroll. A new website is here to help. MyFreeTaxesWA.org connects Washington residents with IRS-certified volunteer tax professionals who can offer in-person or virtual tax help. As the name implies, it’s a free service and is available in multiple languages. The effort is funded through…

Downtown Seattle Foot Traffic is Up, Thanks to Amazon

Downtown Seattle Foot Traffic is Up, Thanks to Amazon

Still lags pre-pandemic numbers

Amazon’s return-to-office mandate resulted in a measurable increase among downtown Seattle office workers in January, but the numbers still aren’t anywhere near where they were six years ago. The Downtown Seattle Association’s Revitalization Dashboard shows foot traffic in neighborhoods where Amazon’s offices are located (South Lake Union and Denny Regrade) at 74% of that of…

Goodbye Seattle Freeze. Hello Seattle Bear Hug

Goodbye Seattle Freeze. Hello Seattle Bear Hug

US Chamber of Connection seeks to unite newcomers to the city

Aaron Hurst is outgoing. He’s friendly. After just a brief conversation with him, it’s difficult to imagine he would have a hard time making friends. That, however, is exactly what happened when he moved to Seattle from Brooklyn about 10 years ago. His wife, Kara, had just landed her “dream job” as Amazon’s chief sustainability…

UW Names Robert J. Jones New President

UW Names Robert J. Jones New President

Jones replaces Ana Mari Cauce, who is retiring

The University of Washington has named Robert J. Jones its 34th president. Jones, who has spent the past nine years as chancellor at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, replaces Ana Mari Cauce, who will have held the role for 10 years at the end of the academic year in June. Jones, who also previously served…