Skip to content

Seattle Culture

In Seattle, Renting is King

The annual savings between renting and buying is significant

By Seattle Mag July 12, 2024

Single-story house with a well-maintained yard and a "For Rent" sign in the front. A white picket fence and brick pillars frame the entrance. The house features green shutters and a covered porch, making it a charming option for those renting in Seattle.
Photo by Monkey Business Images / Shutterstock

With rising rates, Seattle may not exactly be a renter’s paradise. But for those on a budget, renting certainly beats buying.

Using data from Seattle-based Zillow, Creditnews Research says only six cities across the United States have a bigger gap between renting and total homeownership costs. The average home price in the Puget Sound region is $753,414, and average total cost is more than $6,900 per month. Contrast that with average rent of $2,250, and residents here pay a staggering $4,662 per month extra to own their own homes.

The study considers all homeownership costs, not just mortgage payments. Think insurance, taxes, and renovation expenses.

“The metros with the highest homeownership costs relative to renting are mainly located on the West Coast, in Hawaii, and parts of the Northeast,” the report notes. “The smallest differences are in the South and Rust Belt.”

The greater San Jose holds the dubious No. 1 ranking, with the total difference between owning and renting more than $11,000. The metro areas of San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Diego, Honolulu and Oxnard-Thousand Oaks, Calif., are the only cities ahead of Seattle.

The smallest differences are in Jackson, Miss.; El Paso, Texas; and Toledo, Ohio. The average home price in Jackson and Toledo is less than $190,000.

The federal Department of Housing and Urban Development says, in general, that households that spend more than 30% of their income on housing are considered at risk. The city of Seattle says nearly 46,000 households across the city are spending more than half of their incomes on housing costs, noting that median home values skyrocketed by 80% between 2010 and 2019, while King County median incomes rose only 55%.

Rent also continues to rise. Rental rates rose almost 92% between 2010 and 2020, according to software company Self Financial.

Follow Us

The Pulse: That Summer Light

The Pulse: That Summer Light

Seattle’s tooth fairy and an I-5 meltdown

It hit 94 on Wednesday — the hottest day of the year so far. Today’s cooler, breezy even, and I’m not complaining. Everything’s green, and the water’s sparkling. Summer in Seattle really is the best. Last night was our last 9 p.m. sunset for a while and my husband and I made the most of…

The World Within Reach

The World Within Reach

This summer, staying local doesn’t have to mean staying still. Explore Seattle as a global journey.

Summer in Seattle can be hard to give up — the long awaited celebration of bright sunshine, inviting hills and welcoming bodies of water. For those deciding to stay local this season, the avid, curious traveler can still explore the city as a portal to travel abroad. A mosaic of global cultures awaits, with food,…

Playtime on the Pier

Playtime on the Pier

Seattle’s long-awaited Pier 58 reopens with a jellyfish tower and sweeping views

Seattle pulled it off. After years of construction, detours, and debate, the city is getting another major piece of its waterfront back. Pier 58 officially reopens Friday, July 25, as part of the 20-acre Waterfront Park transformation. What was once a crumbling concrete deck is now a bright, marine-themed play zone with a 25-foot jellyfish-inspired…

The Pulse: Sun Baked

The Pulse: Sun Baked

Subaru drivers and late bloomers

Are you ready? We’re supposed to hit 80 degrees next week. Time to get creative with your fashion choices and cooling devices, Seattle. Also — who’s following the Tour de France? I tore through the Netflix documentary and now I’m all in. Jonas Vingegaard has my whole heart. I hope he pulls through after a…