Skip to content

Counter Culture

Read More ›

Counter Culture: Three Great Burgers Hiding in Plain Sight

A Ballard sandwich shop, a private club in South Lake Union, and a Mountlake Terrace Greek restaurant serve up burgers worth seeking out.

A cheeseburger from The Collective served on a bun with sliced pickles and mustard, widely considered one of the best burgers in Seattle.
Mean Sandwich’s D.A.M. burger was one of three I tried in my search for a great burger.
Photo courtesy of MEAN Sandwich

Sometimes you want a burger. You just don’t want a burger joint.

Maybe the person across the table has something else in mind, maybe you’re looking for a new neighborhood spot, or maybe you’ve learned that a burger can be particularly good when it has to earn its place on a menu devoted to other things. So I went looking beyond the usual burger spots. The search turned up three very different burgers, each worth ordering even when the rest of the menu is making a strong case for your attention.

A cheeseburger cut in half on a white plate, served alongside a bowl of soup, making it one of our best burgers.
Housemade pickles and yellow mustard give Mean Sandwich’s D.A.M. burger its sharp, mouthwatering punch.
Photo by Brandon Ferguson

Mean Sandwich

Ballard and Bellevue 

At a place called Mean Sandwich, it takes some conviction to pass over the inventive sandwiches and order a burger. The D.A.M. burger rewards that decision. Two patties get the smashburger treatment, with the char and firm, browned edges that make this style so satisfying. There’s plenty of beef flavor here. But the ingredients that really grab your attention are the housemade pickles and yellow mustard.

The first bite gets your salivary glands going. The pickles bring a sharp tang, the mustard follows with its own punch, and together they cut through the richness of the meat and American cheese. You get all that browned beef without losing the brighter flavors around it. It’s a rich, satisfying burger, with just the right amount of acidity to balance it out.

The Ballard shop now has company: Mean Sandwich has added a downtown Bellevue location, giving Eastside burger seekers a shorter route to the D.A.M. burger.

Find it: Mean Sandwich, 1510 NW Leary Way, Seattle; and 500 Bellevue Way NE, second floor of Lincoln South Food Hall, Bellevue.

A hamburger on a toasted pretzel bun, cut in half on a white plate and ready for our counter culture food guide.
The Collective’s burger pairs a charred, juicy patty with the satisfying chew of a pretzel bun.
Photo by Brandon Ferguson

The Collective

South Lake Union

At The Collective, the burger is easy to overlook. It’s the lone burger among dishes with considerably loftier ambitions. But one bite makes it clear that someone in the kitchen knows their way around a good hamburger. 

Kobe beef, bacon, white cheddar, butter lettuce, and thousand island dressing come together on a pretzel bun. It’s a promising lineup, but the cooking is what keeps bringing me back. The outside of the patty develops enough char for a little crunch; inside, it stays juicy. That contrast has been consistently excellent.

Then there’s the bun. We spend plenty of time talking about beef and toppings, but bread can make or break a burger. This pretzel bun gives just enough resistance as you bite through it, adding a satisfying chew to the juicy beef and melted cheddar. It deserves some credit of its own. On a menu that gives you plenty of reasons to order something more elaborate, this burger holds its own.

Find it: The Collective, 400 Dexter Ave. N., Seattle. The Collective is a private club; check current public dining reservations through OpenTable before visiting.

A sliced cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, and onion on a plate, featured in our burger guide.
The Time Out Burger, pictured with an extra patty, delivers bacon, two cheeses, and old-fashioned diner satisfaction.
Photo by Brandon Ferguson

Time Out

Mountlake Terrace

Time Out is a family-owned Greek restaurant whose comfort food is worth the drive from Seattle. It also happens to make the kind of burger that reminds you how satisfying an old-fashioned diner burger can be.

The signature Time Out Burger starts with a one-third-pound beef patty and adds two thick strips of bacon, American and Swiss cheeses, grilled mushrooms and onions, lettuce, tomato, raw onion, pickles, and mayo on a Kaiser roll. I ordered mine with a second patty, a detail worth keeping in mind when looking at the photo.

The patties are pressed enough to have a dense, substantial bite, without going quite as far as a smashburger. The bacon is thick enough to look perfectly at home beside a stack of pancakes, and the two cheeses melt around the beef, complementing the smoky bacon and grilled onions. It’s a generous, deeply comforting burger from a restaurant that already gives you plenty of reasons to visit. Choosing between it and the Greek food may be the hardest part of the trip.

Find it: Time Out Greek & American Restaurant, 5807 244th St. SW, Mountlake Terrace.

Special thanks to my friend David Shulman, entrepreneur and founder of the Seattle Film Institute, who graciously joined me on this burger search. Finding a great neighborhood meal is a pleasure. Having a good friend across the table makes it even better.

About Counter Culture

Brandon Ferguson is a CFO by trade but a foodie at heart. He has a passion for small, humble restaurants that rarely make it onto the radar of mainstream food critics or glossy dining guides. Join him as he discovers warmth, tradition, and authenticity along with great food.

The Salmon Connection: Don’t Miss Bristol Bay Salmon Week

The Salmon Connection: Don’t Miss Bristol Bay Salmon Week

Seattle-area chefs put wild Alaska sockeye in the spotlight Nov. 14-21, with special dishes that celebrate the fish and the people who bring it to our tables.

Every June, Toby Bloom heads to Alaska for a summer that involves very little time on land. By midmonth, he’s aboard a commercial fishing boat in Bristol Bay with three crewmen, catching wild sockeye salmon. They’ll spend the next several weeks working on the water, heading into town only when they need something that can’t…

Restaurant Roundup: Literary Libations and Tequila on the Docks

Restaurant Roundup: Literary Libations and Tequila on the Docks

Here’s what was served up recently in the Emerald City.

There are still three weeks until Thanksgiving, but the spread of offerings this year at Seattle-area hotels is already impressive. Whether you’re traveling in the city or simply don’t want to deal with dirty dishes, the cornucopia overfloweth. Enjoy a feast at the Four Seasons’ recently remodeled Goldfinch Tavern, or a three-course meal at The…

Best Coffee Shop: Drip Drip Coffeehouse

Best Coffee Shop: Drip Drip Coffeehouse

This women- owned and minority-operated coffee shop gained popularity for its Vietnamese-style coffee and matcha flights. The former is brewed with a phin—a Vietnamese coffee press in which hot water slowly drips through coffee grounds—yielding a bold, concentrated brew. Drip Drip’s phin-brewed coffee comes in sweet and savory flavors, including banana, salted egg yolk, coconut…

Best Brewery: Stoup Brewing

Best Brewery: Stoup Brewing

Like any good craft brewery, Stoup has a little chaos to it. Dogs tuck under tables, kids tear into snacks, food trucks hum in the background, and friends squeeze together at long tables. Husband-and-wife Brad Benson and Lara Zahaba opened the original Ballard brewery with their friend Robyn Schumacher in 2013, amid the neighborhood’s craft-brewery…